Moose: A Memoir
Sunday, January 10, 2010 at 12:58PM 16. Read 30 books I haven’t read before and blog about them. (19/30)
Moose: A Memoir
by Stephanie Klein
I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with Stephanie Klein. I really adore some of the things she writes/says (sometimes she video blogs) and I get really annoyed or turned off by other things she writes/says. Not surprisingly, my reaction to her fat camp memoir is the same. In Moose, "Klein shares the cutting details of what it truly feels like to be an overweight child, from the stinging taunts of classmates, to the off-color remarks of her own father, to her thin mother's compulsive dissatisfaction with her own body" (Amazon).
So many of the details and events in the book resonated with me. I went to summer camp; it wasn't a "fat camp" yet many of the details were achingly familiar (except I never made out with anyone at summer camp). The Amazon review is right in that Klein shares a lot of remarkably familiar details of what it's like to grow up as a fat kid.
That said, most of Klein's story is different from my own and was truly fascinating to read. She mentions several times how she was interested in sex much younger than many of her classmates and friends and I couldn't help but link that to later issues with body image and eating. Klein, though, never explicitly makes the link which makes me wonder if we, the readers, were meant to make it or if it just really hadn't occurred to her.
My main issue with the book, the one that left me feeling unsatisfied with it, is the writing - in particular, the choices made at the end of the text. The book is called Moose because that was a name the kids at school called Klein, but it feels like a stretch when Klein extends this into her college years at the end of the book. The book is primarily about her summer "fat" camp experiences and the end feels like it betrays this purpose by meandering into other topics. The story deserves a much better wrap-up than it has. Even framing those final scenes/anecdotes/reflections as a prologue would have been an improvement. It makes me wonder about her editor(s).
I did mostly enjoy the book, though, and will continue to read her blog. She has a unique take on life that I haven't seen anywhere else and I am interested to see what else she has to say.
















